Cancel hound alert: Canadian town cancels did very well at Sparks

Cancel hound alert: Canadian town cancels did very well at Sparks

Sparks Auctions has released realised prices for their May event. Just before the auction, I wrote about a couple of lots that were intriguing, but before I get to them, there were two lots I missed that are wowing me.

Lot 1202, 2000 stamps with early Ontario town cancels, sold nicely over expectations. This was a smorgasbord of 38 stock sheets valued at $2,000 and sold for $2,500 (with the buyer’s premium $2,850).  Included were higher value small Queens,  Jubilee issues,  QV Maple Leafs and Numerals with cancels from all over the province.  It looks like a fascinating grouping to enjoy.  Someone is going to have a lot of fun with it.

It was a good auction for cancel hounds.  Lot 1283, another town cancel collection, this time from New Brunswick  (1840s to 1930s) offered more than 600 covers and postcards including some rare and one of a kind marks. 1283 included fancy corks which are my favourite type of cancels, especially if they are on small Queens. My own collection defines the word modest, but that doesn’t stop me from pouring over them again and again. There’s always something new to pick out.  I can’t tell you how often I’ve rearranged them – first by cancel, then by town and sometimes by colour variation. What can I say, it whiles away cold Canadian winter nights. The collection was pegged at $2,000 as well, but sold for $3,000 ($3,450 with buyer’s premium).  After looking through the list of rare or scare cancels, I can see how someone would pay that. I have a reoccurring fantasy of walking into an auction with $20,000 to play with.  Somehow I think I’d come away with mostly pioneer airmail, but there would always be a few dollars to spare for a lot or two of fancy cancels.

Back in May, I positively oozed over the early beaver stamps, including a couple that were within budget collectors range and one that ended up being sold for a budget price.  Starting with lot 2, an imperf pair 3d beavers,  with a Unitrade catalogue value of $1,600 sold for just $525. The cancels are outstanding on this pair.   Just goes to show, you can never really anticipate what’s going to happen on auction day. 

1851 3d red Beaver Imperforate, on Laid Paper - courtesy Sparks Auctions

Lot 17, a lovely little stamp with a strong #8 Chatham cancel sold for $10 under estimate at $40.  For early Canadian collectors,  #4ii 1852 3d orange red Beaver Imperforate ended up as a solid buy. 

8 #4ii 1852 3d orange red Beaver Imperforate, used with ideal strike of 4-ring #8 (Chatham), with four clear to large margins but with two tiny pinholes. image courtesy Sparks Auctions

Lot 119 was the one that captured me. Over 2,000 small Queens and 13 covers, a cancel hounds delight, was listed at $300. This bargain for the right collector, sold for way under the estimate at $170.

So there were some real winners in the auction and if you want to see the results for Auction 27 the pdf is available at Sparks’ website now. You can still download the catalogues for the auction – https://sparks-auctions.com/ They haven’t posted information on Auction 28, but it’s slated for sometime in Sept.  I did pull one tidbit from their page that I’ll be watching for –  “specialized collections of Canadian air mail and first flights”. I can’t wait to see what is included. I’ll keep you posted.

** all images courtesy Sparks Auctions

Good value lots at Sparks early Canadian pence issue auction

Good value lots at Sparks early Canadian pence issue auction

Sparks Auctions in Ottawa, Ontario has 41 lots of early Canadian pence issues up for auction at the end of May. There are the usual “out of my league” offerings I enjoy mooning over, like lot 40 showcasing a  #10 6d Consort Imperforate on cover, dating to 1858. Sent from Montreal to Boston, the cover has a crisp stamp and two clear cancels and considered Very Fine.  The catalogue price is $10,000, so yea, just a bit out of my price range but enjoyable to look at even from afar.

About half the pence issues are the early beaver stamps #1 & 4 including this imperf pair:

1851 3d red Beaver Imperforate, on Laid Paper - courtesy Sparks Auctions

Any cancel hound will appreciate the centering and clearness of the target cancels.  Combined with the strong, visible margins, this a real score. (see page six of Part 1 — Canada & British North America catalogue). It’s listed for $1,600, and will be interesting to see what it actually goes for.

There are some value lots in this listing. Lot 17 offers a #4ii 1852 3d orange/red Beaver imperforate with a great 4-ring #8 (Chatham, Ontario) cancel and large margins. As with the others, the cancel is well centred but not so heavy as to obliterate the beaver offering a nice balance. The 8 is still sharp and attractive. The stamp has some flaws, two pinholes, so that hurts the price a bit. Doubtful the pin holes will even be noticeable and offers a real chance for new or budget collectors to snag a true Canadian classic. It’s valued at $50.  See page 7 in the same catalogue.

8 #4ii 1852 3d orange red Beaver Imperforate, used with ideal strike of 4-ring #8 . image courtesy Sparks Auctions
For small Queen collectors, there are quite a few lots, each containing hundreds of stamps ranging from $100 to the thousands. For me, the standout is 119:

“#37, 41 1870s to 1890s 3c Small Queen Lot, in a thick stock book, with well over 2,000 used stamps plus about 13 (mostly faulty) covers. We note more than usual early 1870-72 shades than is usually seen in this type of lot, with pages full. We also note several carmine rose shades from 1888-89, many 11½x12 perfs, 15 copies with imprints, many town cancels, and more. ”

Listed at $300, and over 2000 stamps, this could supply hours of investigating fun.

Check out all the lots at https://sparks-auctions.com/ sale 27 on May 29th-30th, 2018.

** all images courtesy Sparks Auctions

Canadian philately – the amazing 1859 5c beaver stamp

Canadian philately – the amazing 1859 5c beaver stamp

July 1859 – pre-Confederation Canadian 5c beaver stamp

Canadian philately - 5 c beaver beaver stamp, 1859

5 cent beaver stamp

Cat #15 Scott’s & Unitrade Specialized Canadian and SG #31 (listed under Colony of Canada)

American Bank Note Company – New York – wove papers

Perforations: 11.75, 12 x 11.75, 11.75 x 12, 12 | Designed by Sir Sandford Fleming

This has to be one of my all-time favourite Canadian stamps, the 5c beaver stamp. It’s the one I coveted the most when I began collecting. I’d look at it, through the case in the local hobby store and wonder what it would be like to own it. I grew up with stories of the fur trade in Canada, the Coureurs des bois and the Hudson’s Bay Company, so the history that tiny piece of coloured paper represented was deeply ingrained. I often think it’s a slightly wonky, stoned beaver with Godzilla proportions on that small waterfall but still … it was THE STAMP, as far as my young collector self was concerned.

Sir Sanford Fleming

Sir Sanford Fleming Archives Canada/C-14128

Sir Sanford Fleming

The #15 beaver stamp re-used the original Sir Sandford design from the first stamp issued, pre-Confederation (pre independence) 23 April 1851 for the Province of Canada. Sir Sandford Fleming (yes, he of railroad and Standard Time fame) designed the original 3 pence beaver, in collaboration with Canada’s first post master general, the Honourable James Morris. The stamp is notable because it was the first official stamp issued, anywhere, with an animal on it. Stamps normally depicted coat of arms, royalty, presidents, not tree gnawing rodents.

The Right Honourable Rodent, known by his formal name Castor Canadensis or North American beaver, played a crucial part in the development of Canada and is one of the country’s national symbols. How important? This important:

Beaver sculpture Centre Block on Canadian Parliament

Looking out over Ottawa & protecting Parliament

That angry, noble looking fellow can be found over the Centre Block entrance on Parliament Hill.

And here:

Canadian nickel - reverse side

The iconic 5c nickel

And finally:

Photo of a Beaver Tail snacks

Beaver tails!

Ok, the last one not so much. It’s a sugary, delicious snack made of deep fried dough and lots of .. well .. sugar. If you come to Canada, try you have to try a Beaver Tail, it’s the law… trust me

Of beaver hats and fur trading posts

Deep fried snacks aside … the demand for beaver pelts and cod drove the economic engine of early Canada. Beaver hats were all the fashion in Europe for 250 yrs. Canada was a rich source of the must have fur, pushing exploration and later settlements across the continent. One of the great fur trading companies still exists  (although as a department store, rather than trading post) – the HBC, or Hudson’s Bay Company, founded May 2, 1670. At one point, it was the single largest land over in the world – owning rights to about 15% of Canadian territory.

The history of the fur trade and the role beavers played in it, is sewn into the fabric of Canada’s identity. So much so, that in March 24, 1975, the beaver was finally given official recognition as an emblem of Canada, although most of us grew up believing it already was.

Photo of Alfred Jones - engraver, pres American Bank Note Co

Alfred Jones, engraver

In 1851, Sir Sandford picked the beaver for the first stamp of the Province of Canada because of it’s importance. It’s also meshed nicely with the symbolism of a young country busily building itself. It’s believed the engraver was Alfred Jones (1819-1900) (see photo to the right) of the American Bank Note company. He was a renowned engraver and later president of ABN.

The engraving was used on 4 stamps over the next 8-9 years. Using the Scott’s numbering they are:

  • #1 issued April 23, 1851, imperforate (250,200 printed by Rawdon, Wright, Hatch & Edson)
  • #4 issued April 17, 1852, imperforate (2,850,300 printed by Rawdon, Wright, Hatch & Edson)
  • #12 issued January 1859 with 11.75 perfs (449,900 printed by Rawdon, Wright, Hatch & Edson)
  • And finally July 1859, #15 with a variety of perfs 11.75, 12 x 11.75, 11.75 x 12, 12 (39,792,172 printed by American Bank Note Company)

Quick note: Rawdon, Wright, Hatch & Edson merged with 8 other printing firms in 1858 to form the American Bank Note Company.

1859 – 1864 series

Today’s article focuses on the 4th printing. The 1859-1864 series (stamps 14 through to 20) were the first cent issues printed in Canada. In 1857, the Currency Act changed provincial money to the decimal system, hence the change from pence to penny. The new stamps reflected the change.

This stamp is eminently affordable for the novice collector, but still offers interesting challenges to experts. There are many variations in shades, paper types, re-entries and errors. Here are the better known ones:

  • Colours – vermillion, brick red, deep red and orange red
  • Paper – very thick, very thin, ribbed

Re-entry – so many, it’s hard to list them. 2 types of major re-entries are well known. According to Unitrade, plate 100 was reused (touched up and re-entered) 10 times which resulted in 11 separate identifiable plate entries, which calculates to a possible 1100 different re-entries to collect.

Errors – as with re-entries, there are many errors to collect:

  • Rock in the waterfall
  • Log in waterfall
  • Leaping fish in the waterfall
  • Split beaver
  • Low moon
  • Comet over the sun
  • High moon
  • Broken antenna
  • Trembling pines

To further complicate things, an imperforate sheet was issued (100 stamps), with no gum (#15a). These are the unicorns of the Canadian stamp world. Very rare and tons of fakes. An authenticated #15a could potentially fetch up to $17,000 if it came up at auction. However, only 2 blocks and two pairs are known to exist. It’s pretty easy to fake a single copy so avoid any offerings unless you get it authenticated.

High price variations aside, this is an early pre-Confederation stamp you could spend years researching while on a budget. A mint, Fine with original gum will cost around $600. Be careful who you buy it from. Regummed stamps are not unusual. If you simply want to own one (or more) you can get them for as little as $3 or $4 for used or $40 mint space filler. They have defects but are attractive and fun to collect. If you are a cancel hound, you will have a wealth of choice for very little investment. To me, used issues present far more of a challenge and much more fun.  I’ve bought a handful over the years, picked because of the interesting cancels, like these ones:

5c beavers - used 1859

Lovely row of 5c beaver stamps

Bullseye cancel

My favourite is the one on the far right with the bullseye cancel:

Canadian beaver stamp 5c w/ bullseye cancel

Bullseye

Now here’s the funny thing about this stamp. #15 was printed 31 times producing 39,100,000 stamps. Ponder that for a moment. When Canada became independent in 1867, the entire population of the new found country was just shy of 3.5 million people. Right now, the population of the country is hovering around 35 million. More stamps were issued than the entire population of Canada now.

That means a rich field to pick from, regardless your budget.

Where to find information on the 5c beaver stamp

If you decide to expand your collection into the #15, you might want to invest in a few catalogues or see if your local library has any of these:

Unitrade Specialized Canadian Catalogue – an older copy will do. The prices don’t change much to make it imperative to have the latest catalogue. It has a decent selection of the variations.

Stanley Gibbons Commonwealth & Empire Stamps – excellent catalogue and breaks Canada down nicely for the pre-Confederation stamps. Just look under Colony of Canada for this issue. It’s #31.

Specialized Edition Canadian Philatelic E.F.O.’s – for sheer number of variations listed, this is the go to book. It has excellent full colour blow ups of the errors and variations, helping with identification. However, the catalogue is seriously irritating if you think linearly. You’ll have to hopscotch all around the book because each type of variation has it’s own section. Re-entries are on one part, then you’ll have to flip over to colour variations and again flip around to find plate errors and so on. I’d prefer to see the book lay out the errors stamp by stamp so there’s far less page skipping to be done.  Another irritant is the numbering system. They use neither the Scott’s nor Stanley Gibbons numbering.

The Five Cent Beaver Stamp of Canada by Geoffrey Whitworth ISBN-10: 0900631120 and ISBN-13: 978-0900631122. ) – speaking of unicorns.  Very hard to come by now. It was published by London : Royal Philatelic Society, 1985, sold for 7 pounds 50 and is incredibly difficult to find. I’m still looking for my own copy. It’s extensive and the definitive study for any collector. If you see it, grab it. You can post a bragging comment below and I’ll be suitably jealous. It’s a slim book, 90 pages but chocked full of invaluable details.

Read more:

  • As always, there are many resources online if you want to chase up information. Start with Collections Canada’s archived site on the .05c Beaver Stamp The article is no longer available. Collections Canada has moved the page and I haven’t been able to locate it.
  • The Bank of Canada has a pdf on the history of Canada’s switch from pence to pennies titled Currency Reform. It’s well written, entertaining and free so don’t let the dry as dust name put you off.
  • A short bio of engraver Alfred Jones can be found courtesy of Collections Canada The article is no longer available. Collections Canada has moved the page and I haven’t been able to locate it.
  • And of course Sir Sanford Fleming could fill a book but the Canadian Encyclopedia is a good starting point
  • The Canadian Encyclopedia has brief history of the fur trade in Canada
  • Canada’s First People has a super page on both the fur trade and the role the First Nations people played in it
  • Photo of beaver over Centre Block by By D. Gordon E. Robertson – Own work, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=15734547
  • Portrait of Alfred Jones, engraved by Robert Savage. Courtesy of Gene Hessler

FINAL NOTE: I’m a bit gobsmacked at how many photos of ferets, muskrats, pack rats, otters and prairie dogs on the internet are labeled “Beaver”. Here’s a tip – beavers don’t have fluffy tails. Nor do they float around the water on their backs or amble about in deserts nibbling seeds.  In case you are momentarily confused, this is a beaver:

North American Beaver

Canada – 1859 5c beaver stamp & fancy cancels

Canada – 1859 5c beaver stamp & fancy cancels

I picked up a small set of the 1859 Canadian beaver stamp (Scott’s #15) years ago. Top qualify ones were out of my budget range at the time, so I looked around for some flawed ones – just so I could have these famous stamps in my collection.  Although I couldn’t afford the layout hundreds of dollars for a good stamp, I could afford the “defects”.  They are space fillers, but I love them anyway. I looked around for ones with good cancel marks – increases the value in my not so humble opinion.

The set displayed here have very visible number obliteration marks.  You can research the cancel marks (obliterations) and if you are lucky, figure out where it was sent from.   Cancels, in this time period were, well, varied is an understatement. I have some with ring cancels, dates, numbers, fancy cancels and big blobs of ink. Not all have been catalogued and sometimes it’s a guessing game as to the post office that marked them.

1851 Sir Sandford Fleming Beaver Stamp

An earlier 3 penny beaver was issued in 1851, it doesn’t have the perfs and is much harder to come by and much more expensive. The 5 cent issue uses the same design, but it was part of the first set of stamps issued using the new decimal currency. The beaver stamp was designed by  Sir Sandford Fleming in Toronto. For none Canadians, the beaver was picked because of its historical importance in the development of Canada.  You can read more on it here.

A mint, with original gum will set you back around $650. But you have to be wary of any old stamp with “original” gum. Many are re-gummed by unethical sellers to increase the value of the stamp. Always get an expert opinion before buying an original gum stamp.  However, if you simply want to have them in your collection, or are a cancel fan, you can pick them up for as low as $2 a piece. A great bargain, lots of fun.

My Modest Selection of 1859 Beaver Stamps

Canada 1859 beaver stamp
Canada 1859 beaver stampCanada 1859 beaver stampCanada 1859 beaver stamp

The #7 cancels, I suspect came from St. John’s NB. It’s fairly close to a cancel shown in the **Canadian Fancy Cancellations of the Nineteenth Century catalogue.  I can’t find a match for the 6 ring cancel (second from last in stamp shown).  Post masters often made their own unofficial obliteration marks and not all of them have been catalogued. The ringed cancels were very popular so hard to trace. The stamp with the number 4 may have been from Owen Sound. If you look closely, you can make out a number in front of the 4. It might be another 4. If so, Owen Sound is the likely origin. But that’s a bit of guess work on my part.

Notes:

**Canadian Fancy Cancellations of the Nineteenth Century, 1961 by K.M. Day & E.A. Smythies or 2nd ed 1981 can still be purchased, second hand through Canadian stamp collector stores for a reasonable price or at AbeBooks.

You can learn more about Fancy Cancels at the BNAPS website – http://www.bnaps.org/hhl/n-fcm.htm
Their website is a rich resource of British North American philately, including a listing of known Fancy Cancels.